The mitochondrial calcium uniporter is a highly selective ion channel composed of species-and tissue-specific structural and regulatory subunits. However, the contribution of each component to uniporter-mediated activity still remains unclear. Here, we employ an evolutionary and synthetic biology approach to investigate the functional inter-dependence between the pore-forming subunit MCU and the EF-hand protein MICU1. Using phylogenetic profiling and genetic complementation analyses, we show that MCU and MICU1 constitute the minimal eukaryotic unit of the uniporter, pointing towards a strong selective pressure behind their co-occurrence. Heterologous reconstitution of MCU-mediated and MICU1-gated mitochondrial calcium entry?in vivoin yeast cells demonstrates that MICU1?per se?is essential to protect yeast from MCU-dependent manganese cytotoxicity. Accordingly, MICU1 deletion significantly sensitizes human HEK-293 cells to manganese-induced stress. Our study identifies a critical role of MICU1 in the regulation of MCU ion selectivity, with potential implications for patients with MICU1 deficiency.