Sphingolipids are widespread, abundant, and essential lipids in plants and in other eukaryotes. Glycosyl inositol phosphorylceramides (GIPCs) are the most abundant class of plant sphingolipids, and are enriched in the plasma membrane of plant cells. They have been difficult to study due to lethal or pleiotropic mutant phenotypes. To overcome this, we developed a CRISPR/Cas9-based method for generating multiple and varied knockdown and knockout populations of mutants in a given gene of interest in the model moss Physcomitrium patens. This system is uniquely convenient due to the predominantly haploid state of the Physcomitrium life cycle, and totipotency of Physcomitrium protoplasts used for transformation. We used this approach to target the INOSITOL PHOSPHORYLCERAMIDE SYNTHASE (IPCS) gene family, which catalyzes the first, committed step in the synthesis of GIPCs. We isolated knockout single mutants and knockdown higher-order mutants showing a spectrum of deficiencies in GIPC content. Remarkably, we also identified two mutant alleles accumulating inositol phosphorylceramides, the direct products of IPCS activity, and provide our best explanation for this unexpected phenotype. Our approach is broadly applicable for studying essential genes and gene families, and for obtaining unusual lesions within a gene of interest.