Amyloidogenesis is significant in both protein function and pathology. Amyloid formation of folded, globular proteins is commonly initiated by partial or complete unfolding. However, how this unfolding event is triggered for proteins that are otherwise stable in their native environments is not well understood. The accumulation of the immunoglobulin protein β2-microglobulin (β2m) into amyloid plaques in the joints of long-term hemodialysis patients is the hallmark of dialysis-related amyloidosis (DRA). While β2m does not form amyloid unassisted near neutral pH in vitro, the localization of β2m deposits to joint spaces suggests a role for the local extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins, specifically collagens, in promoting amyloid formation. Indeed, collagen and other ECM components have been observed to facilitate β2m amyloid formation, but the large size and anisotropy of the complex, combined with the low affinity of these interactions, have limited atomic-level elucidation of the amyloid-promoting mechanism(s) by these molecules. Using solution NMR approaches that uniquely probe weak interactions in large molecular weight complexes, we are able to map the binding interfaces on β2m for collagen I and detect collagen I-induced μs-ms time-scale dynamics in the β2m backbone. By combining solution NMR relaxation methods and 15N-dark-state exchange saturation transfer experiments, we propose a model in which weak, multimodal collagen I-β2m interactions promote exchange with a minor population of amyloid-competent species to induce fibrillogenesis. The results portray the intimate role of the environment in switching an innocuous protein into an amyloid-competent state, rationalizing the localization of amyloid deposits in DRA.